| Regimental number | 355 |
| Date of birth | |
| Place of birth | Parkside, South Australia |
| School | Parkside Public School, Adelaide, South Australia |
| Religion | Methodist |
| Occupation | Blacksmith |
| Address | 3 South Railway Parade, Goodwood, South Australia |
| Marital status | Married |
| Age at embarkation | 30 |
| Next of kin | Wife, Mrs Sarah Adelaide May Pengilly, 3 South Railway Parade, Goodwood, South Australia |
| Previous military service | Served for 4 years in the 10th Infantry Regiment, Citizen Military Forces. Previously rejected for AIF enlistment on account of deficient teeth. |
| Enlistment date | |
| Rank on enlistment | Private |
| Unit name | 43rd Battalion, Machine Gun Section |
| AWM Embarkation Roll number | 23/60/1 |
| Embarkation details | Unit embarked from Adelaide, South Australia, on board HMAT A19 Afric on |
| Rank from Nominal Roll | Private |
| Unit from Nominal Roll | 43rd Battalion |
| Fate | Killed in Action |
| Age at death from cemetery records | 31 |
| Place of burial | No known grave |
| Commemoration details | The Ypres (Menin Gate) Memorial (Panel 27), Belgium The Menin Gate Memorial (so named because the road led to the town of Menin) was constructed on the site of a gateway in the eastern walls of the old Flemish town of Ypres, Belgium, where hundreds of thousands of allied troops passed on their way to the front, the Ypres salient, the site from April 1915 to the end of the war of some of the fiercest fighting of the war. The Memorial was conceived as a monument to the 350,000 men of the British Empire who fought in the campaign. Inside the arch, on tablets of Portland stone, are inscribed the names of 56,000 men, including 6,178 Australians, who served in the Ypres campaign and who have no known grave. The opening of the Menin Gate Memorial on 24 July 1927 so moved the Australian artist Will Longstaff that he painted 'The Menin Gate at Midnight', which portrays a ghostly army of the dead marching past the Menin Gate. The painting now hangs in the Australian War Memorial, Canberra, at the entrance of which are two medieval stone lions presented to the Memorial by the City of Ypres in 1936. Since the 1930s, with the brief interval of the German occupation in the Second World War, the City of Ypres has conducted a ceremony at the Memorial at dusk each evening to commemorate those who died in the Ypres campaign. |
| Panel number, Roll of Honour, Australian War Memorial | 137 |
| Miscellaneous information from cemetery records | Parents: Richard and Thirza PENGILLY, 34 Fuller Street, Parkside, South Australia; husband of Mrs S. PENGILLY |
| Family/military connections | Brother: 19623 Sergeant Arthur Gordon PENGILLY, 8th Field Artillery Brigade, returned to Australia. |
| Other details |
War service: Western Front Embarked Adelaide, 9 June 1916; disembarked Marseilles, France, 20 July 1916; proceeded on to England. Proceeded overseas to France, 25 November 1916. Killed in action, Belgium, 15 October 1917. Medals: British War Medal, Victory Medal |